SB7 · STATIC-BEAM · Element Benchmarks

Simply-supported beam on a Winkler elastic foundation (CSI 1-013)

Winkler foundation via Point Springs — center deflection & moment vs Timoshenko continuum

PASS +0.000057% error tolerance 0.05% −0.089333 in vs −0.089333 in
§2

Technical features tested

  • elasticBeamColumn — Euler-Bernoulli (bending only)
  • Point Springs (zeroLength) ⇒ Winkler foundation
  • k_node = k · tributary length (one per interior node)
  • Simply supported, central point load
  • Deflection & moment vs exact continuum (Timoshenko)
§3

Problem description

A prismatic beam spanning between a pin and a roller rests on a continuous elastic (Winkler) foundation and carries a single point load at midspan. The foundation reaction is proportional to the local deflection, so the governing equation is EI y⁗ + k y = 0 away from the load — the classic beam-on-elastic-foundation problem with a closed-form continuum solution. STRIX represents the distributed foundation with production Point Springs (a vertical zeroLength spring at every interior node, stiffness k times the nodal tributary length) and runs the ordinary linear-static pipeline. The lumped-spring discrete model converges to the exact continuum center deflection and moment as the mesh is refined — the same problem, and the same independent reference, documented in CSI SAP2000 verification example 1-013.

P L k pin roller Z X
Figure SB7. Simply-supported beam on a Winkler foundation (nodal vertical springs, stiffness k) under a central point load P.
§4

Geometry, properties & loading

Geometry

Span L
180 in
Section
36 × 36 in
Inertia I
139968 in⁴
β·L (slenderness)
1.716473

Material & foundation

Model
Elastic (Euler)
E
3600 ksi
Subgrade
800 k/ft³
Foundation k
16.6667 kip/in²

Loading & BC

Supports
pin + roller
Load P
500 kip
Location
midspan
Self-weight
off
Analysis
Linear static
§5

Reference solution

  1. Center deflection Uzexact continuum: EI y'''' + k y = 0, pinned-pinned, central P (Timoshenko 1956 Prob 3 p23)= −0.089333 in
  2. Center moment Myexact continuum center moment (sagging), Timoshenko 1956 Prob 3 p23= 17697.995034 kip-in

CSI SAP2000 Software Verification Example 1-013 'Simply Supported Beam on Elastic Foundation'; independent reference = Timoshenko, Strength of Materials Part II, 1956, Problem 3, p.23 (exact continuum solution of EI y'''' + k y = 0, pinned-pinned, central load). Reproduced from scratch by sb7Theory() to −0.0893327 in / 17697.995 k-in, matching CSI's published −0.08933 in / 17698 k-in.

§6

Results comparison

Response quantityProbeSTRIXReferenceΔVerdict
Center deflection Uz (in) N101.uz −0.089333 −0.089333 +0.000057% PASS
Center moment My (kip-in) E101.Miy 17697.862777 17697.995034 −0.00075% PASS
§7

Convergence

MeshCenter Uz (in)Δ
2 elem−0.088539 +0.8881%
4 elem−0.089298 +0.0393%
8 elem−0.089331 +0.0023%
20 elem−0.089333 +0.00010%
40 elem−0.089333 +0.00010%
100 elem−0.089333 +0.00010%
200 elem−0.089333 +0.00010%

Unlike the exact cubic beam element, the lumped nodal foundation is a first-order approximation of the continuous Winkler support, so the discrete model approaches the exact continuum solution as the mesh is refined. The center deflection is essentially converged by a few elements per half-span; the center moment tightens monotonically toward the reference. At the finest mesh (100 elements per half, matching the reference discretization) STRIX reproduces both the exact continuum deflection and moment to under 0.001% — the same independent Timoshenko reference that CSI 1-013 uses.

§8

Conclusion

PASS

STRIX reproduces the reference solution to +0.000057% (tolerance 0.05%). The tested element and its formulation are verified against the reference.

§9

References & analysis files

  1. Timoshenko, S. — Strength of Materials, Part II. Beam on elastic foundation, Problem 3, p.23 (exact continuum solution).
  2. Hetényi, M. — Beams on Elastic Foundation. University of Michigan Press, 1946. Winkler-foundation theory, EI y⁗ + k y = q.
  3. CSI — SAP2000 Software Verification, Example 1-013: Simply Supported Beam on Elastic Foundation (independent reference, Timoshenko 1956).
  4. OpenSees — element zeroLength + uniaxialMaterial Elastic (nodal foundation spring); elasticBeamColumn (Euler-Bernoulli).
Engine
v1.0.6 (opensees.pyd)
Run date
2026-08-19
Record
records/SB7.json
Evidence archive
verif-evidence-eng1.0.6-win-x64.zip · SB7/
sha256
(pending publish)